Rosa luxemburg after 1905 as is wellknown, a number of different strategic lines on the nature of the russian revolution crystallized during and immediately after 1905, out of a debate which received its impetus from the revolutionary upheaval of that year. The accumulation of capital, probably the best book produced by a marxist and socialist thinker since karl marxs opus magnum, emerged from her sudden revelation. Rosa luxemburg 18701919, one of the most remarkable and controversial personalities in the marxist movement, opposes in this book not the bolsheviks quest for power but the way they took power, the way they held power, the way they justified themselves in doing both. Rosa luxemburgs the russian revolution onorato damen. Rosa luxemburg was a participant in this debate within russian and european social. Its outbreak, its unexampled radicalism, its enduring consequences, constitute the clearest condemnation of the lying phrases. Rosa luxemburgs critique of lenins ultra centralistic. Rosa luxemburg and the womens question marxism in her. The russian revolution by rosa luxemburg fundamental significance of the russian revolution the russian revolution is the mightiest event of the world war. Rosa luxemburg on the lack of democracy in soviet russia.
Fundamental signifcance of the russian revolution the bolshevik land policy the nationalities question the constituent assembly. The role model was russia, where the revolution of 1917 had already succeeded but had swiftly led to dictatorship by the party. Luxemburg argues that trade unions, reformist political parties and the expansion of social democracywhile important to the proletariats development of class consciousnesscannot create a socialist society as eduard bernstein, among others, argued. Reform or revolution 3 the challenge of revisionism introducing reform or revolution rosa luxemburgs classic pamphlet reform or revolution also known as social reform or revolution was first published in 1899. Her skull was smashed into pieces and her body was flung in berlins landwehr canal where. She was successively a member of the social democracy of the kingdom of poland and lithuania, the social democratic party of germanyspd, the independent. Rosa luxemburg, revolutionary fighter for workers and. The russian revolution of 1905 proved to be the central experience in rosa luxemburgs life. After rosa luxemburgs manuscript from 1918 on the russian revolution was published in the very early days of 1922 there wereand have continued to bemany discussions on the differences between luxemburg and lenin.
The previous year she criticised the bolshevik dissolution of the constituent assembly. Chapter 1 fundamental significance of the russian revolution. Rosa luxemburg on revolutionary violence springerlink. Brie rosa luxemburg and her symphony on the russian revolution. The new york and brussels offices of the rosa luxemburg stiftung and partners are launching the series of webinars with everything up for grabs.
Rosa luxemburg 5 march 1871 in zamosc, russian poland 15 january 1919 in berlin was a polishjewish marxist politician working in both poland and germany. It must be preceded by a reform introduced from the center, and that in turn must be. Rosa luxemburgs book, written after the 1905 revolution in russia, shows how economic issues can be the catalyst for political demands. In her criticism of the russian revolution she brings to light the ideological roots of lenin and the mensheviks as well as kautsky. The russian revolution chastised lenins party on its agrarian and national selfdetermination stands and its dictatorial and terrorist methods. Rosa luxemburgs letters bring to life a humane socialist whose ideas still resonate today ian thomson sat 19 mar 2011 20. However, little is written about her concept of revolutionary violence, as is usually the case in the context of her criticism of the russian revolution.
These will work towards the transformative and internationalist response the world needs right now. Rosa luxemburg, the russian revolution springerlink. Rosa luxemburg, the russian revolution researchgate. This russian revolution site contains articles, sources and perspectives on events in. She was never able, however, to exercise a decisive influence on the new. A magisterial, definitive account of the upheavals in germany in the wake of the russian revolution.
Rosa luxemburgs views on the russian revolution paperback april 6, 2017 by clara zetkin author see all formats and editions hide other formats and editions. Rosa luxemburg 18711919 is widely regarded as one of the most creative writers of modern socialism and the foremost female theoretician of european radicalism. Luxemburg always remained a believer in democracy as opposed to lenins democratic centralism. Luxemburg, the russian revolution, in rosa luxemburg or. Mbrie rosa luxemburgs symphony on the russian revolution. On january 15, 1919 rosa luxemburg was murdered by farright paramilitary groups, supported by germanys first socialdemocratic chancellor friedrich ebert. Through the two studies that follow, we will begin to explore lenins itinerary of a decolonization of the revolution, covering the question of national selfdetermination and struggles for independence prior to 1917 as well as the imperative to decolonize the russian empire after 1917, starting with the case of the muslim colonies of central asia. The complete works of rosa luxemburg bringing the contributions of this remarkable thinker and personality alive for new generations. Luxemburg was murdered in berlin during the german revolution in 1919. Luxemburg argued that those who choose reform over revolution werent looking for a calmer, more tranquil path to the same goal, but a different goal altogether. Until then, she had believed that germany was the country in which world revolution was most likely to originate. Reform or revolution 3 the challenge of revisionism introducing reform or revolution rosa luxemburg s classic pamphlet reform or revolution also known as social reform or revolution was first published in 1899. Rosa luxemburg on the constituent assembly 1918 rosa luxemburg was a female socialist who, with karl liebknecht, led the spartacist uprising in germany in early 1919. She and fellow spartacist leader karl liebknecht were brutally murdered in.
Download citation rosa luxemburg, the russian revolution the essay concerns the highly controversial pamphlet of rosa luxemburg the russian. Here we attempt to remedy the situation a little with three previously untranslated articles dating from the german revolution. Luxemburg was born in 1871 to a jewish family in russianoccupied poland. Rosa luxemburg is considered as important critic of the economic and political violence which is indispensable to the capitalist system. Rosa luxemburg is often overlooked as one of historys most important marxist thinkers. Leninism or marxism by rosa luxemburg internet archive. Pdf rosa luxemburg is considered as important critic of the economic and. Rosa luxemburgs critique of lenins concept of revolutionary organisation, show the disagreements within the marxist movements in europe in the years preceding 1917. Socialist democracy is not something which begins only in the promised land after the foundations of socialist economy are created.
The aim of the article is to reconstruct her views on revolutionary violence based on less known sources. The essay concerns the highly controversial pamphlet of rosa luxemburg the russian revolution 19181922, in which luxemburg criticizes lenins postrevolutionary policies, in particular his dissolution of the constituent assembly, an elected body. Until then she had believed that germany was the country in which world revolution was most likely to originate. Rosa luxemburg on dictatorship in soviet russia 1918 in late 1918 the german socialist leader rosa luxemburg wrote about the lack of democracy in soviet russia under the bolsheviks. The russian revolution of 1905 proved to be the central experience in luxemburgs life. Fundamental significance of the russian revolution. On 100th anniversary of murder of luxemburg and liebknecht. The russian revolution work by luxemburg britannica. The essay concerns the highly controversial pamphlet of rosa luxemburg the russian revolution 19181922, in which luxemburg criticizes. The russian revolution is the mightiest event of the world war. Rosa luxemburg life, revolutionary activities, works. Rosa luxemburg 5 adar 1871i be namey rozalia luxemburg, zamosc, weichselland, ewro polanya.
Rosa luxemburgs symphony on the russian revolution 4 the manuscript the russian revolution a symphony of democratic socialism let us go back to the vibrant source of this formula. Rosa luxemburgs critique of lenins ultra centralistic party. From these experiences emerged her theory of revolutionary mass action, which. Under the influence of the 1905 russian revolution zetkin and luxemburg argued for a general strike to achieve the political aims of the movement, but the leaders of the reformist wing warned against russian conditions that meant they were warning against a revolutionary development and argued that the masses would go out of control. The russian revolution of 1905 proved to be the central experience in luxemburg s life. The trigger for this manuscript was a footnote by ernst meyer after. Pdf rosa luxemburg on revolutionary violence accepted. Another german communist leader, clara zetkin, wrote a book titled rosa luxemburgs views on the russian revolution in 1922 available since 2017 in english that presents exactly the information needed to clarify luxemburgs positions at that time.
1475 707 52 479 1303 309 476 732 436 568 378 1535 149 644 1512 494 1369 506 1298 902 561 389 1311 1088 413 1387 122 427 814 167 1442 54 845 10 560